Text Only
Search

 
Iran Claims US Faked Video Showing Gulf Standoff


09 January 2008

Still frame from US Navy video of Iranian boat incident in Strait of Hormuz, 6 Jan. 2008
Still frame from US Navy video of Iranian boat incident in Strait of Hormuz, 6 Jan 2008
Iran and the United States are now trading allegations about a recording of the a confrontation between U.S. Navy warships and Iranian Revolutionary Guard speedboats in the Strait of Hormuz earlier this week. The incident took place shortly before President Bush left for his visit to the Middle East. The president has described the Iranian actions as a provocative act. VOA Correspondent Challiss McDonough has more from our Middle East bureau Cairo.

A statement issued by the Iranian Revolutionary Guard on Wednesday accuses the U.S. Defense Department of fabricating the video and audio recordings that show the confrontation between the Iranian speedboats and the U.S. Navy ships.

The Pentagon responded to the Iranian allegation by saying it was absurd and factually incorrect. A spokesman went on to say that the statement reflects a lack of seriousness about the incident.

The Pentagon says the four-minute video was shot from aboard the USS Hopper, a Navy destroyer. It shows several small speedboats maneuvering near the ship and another U.S. vessel.

The Pentagon says the audio recording was from radio communications between the U.S. Navy and the Iranian boats during the incident.

US Navy: "Request you alter course immediately to remain clear."

Iranian boat: "You will explode after a few minutes."

US Navy: "He said we will explode after a few minutes?"

Speaking aboard Air Force One on his way to the Middle East Wednesday, President Bush's National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley again called the incident "a provocative act by the Iranians" and said it came very close to sparking "an altercation" between the two countries' forces. He said Iran would "bear the consequences" of the incident if it happens again. President Bush made similar comments at the White House Tuesday.

Despite the latest Iranian claims that the recordings of the incident were fabricated, Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki has acknowledged that there was an incident, but called it a routine exchange of identification between U.S. and Iranian vessels.

His remarks were translated into English by Iran's state-owned English-language television station, Press TV.

"This is a very common instance, and it has happened in the past, and this is a usual thing, these kinds of communications."

The naval incident came just before President Bush began his current tour of the Middle East. Among other stops, he is scheduled to visit Bahrain, headquarters of the U.S. Navy's Fifth Fleet.

President Bush has said that one of his goals on this Middle East trip is to emphasize to his allies in the Gulf that he continues to see Iran as a threat to regional stability.

Given the timing, the Persian Gulf incident underlines the high level of tension between Iran and the United States over the last year.

But some political and security analysts specializing in Iran believe the incident surprised Tehran as well as the U.S. Navy.

University of Michigan historian and political commentator Juan Cole theorized on his Web site that it may have been the work of a local Revolutionary Guard officer, but probably was not ordered by Tehran.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Bush Calls Iran's Confrontation With US Navy Vessels a Provocative Act
US Releases Video of Naval Incident With Iran
US Commander Disputes Iran on Persian Gulf Incident
 
  Top Story
Automakers Pledge Restructuring in New Bid for Loans  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Motivation for Mumbai Attacks Murky  Audio Clip Available
US Renews Call for Pakistani Cooperation in Mumbai Attack Investigation  Audio Clip Available
Efforts Underway to Defuse Rising Indo-Pakistani Tension  Audio Clip Available
Pakistan Offers to Help Investigate Mumbai Terror Attack  Audio Clip Available
Indian Maritime Forces Rebuff Criticism in Wake of Mumbai Attack  Audio Clip Available
Mumbai Terrorists Aided by Security Lapses, Technology  Audio Clip Available
NATO Agrees to Thaw in Contacts With Russia
Thai PM to Resign, Protesters to Leave Airports  Audio Clip Available
Iraqi Court Sentences Saddam Cousin 'Chemical Ali' to Death  Audio Clip Available
UN Security Council Extends Anti-Piracy Measures off Somali Coast  Audio Clip Available
China Stands by Decision to Postpone Summit with EU  Audio Clip Available
Israeli Airstrike Kills 2 Palestinian Boys in Gaza
Israel Buries Jewish Victims of Mumbai Attack  Audio Clip Available
Zimbabwe Relief Agencies Ramp Up Efforts to Combat Cholera  Audio Clip Available
Obama-Clinton Relationship Will Bring New Dynamic to White House  Audio Clip Available
Obama to Foster US-Europe Relations  Audio Clip Available
US Defense Secretary Comfortable with Obama's Iraq Plan, With Proper Pacing  Audio Clip Available
US Congressional Visitor Center Opens to Public  Audio Clip Available